You are here

Too cold to be skeptical: how consumer reaction to CSR communication is influenced by temperature

RSE : comment la température ambiante influence la perception de la communication
Published on
07 December 2021

The increasingly visible consequences of climate change, coupled with greater expectations around societal issues, have pushed corporate social responsibility (CSR) into the spotlight for both organizations and consumers. While many companies have committed to reducing their impact, others have adopted greenwashing techniques which, when subsequently uncovered, fuel consumer skepticism about environmental advertising claims.

Skepticism is a specific aspect of consumer behavior and Robert Mai, Professor of Marketing at Grenoble Ecole de Management, has demonstrated the significant influence of contextual environmental factors on consumer responses in domains as diverse as sustainability, food consumption, health and digital marketing. Mai has drawn on this expertise to explore the effect of ambient temperature on CSR skepticism. The findings of the study, Too Cold to be Skeptical: How Ambient Temperature Moderates the Effects of CSR Communication, were published this year in the scientific journal Ecological Economics.

Making new connections

"Contextual factors are hugely important and yet they are very much understudied with respect to CSR communication," explains Mai. "We filled this gap in the literature by connecting two different fields of research: the influence of ambient temperature on human behavior and CSR skepticism." Knowing that the human body has a greater tolerance for cold than for heat, the researchers hypothesized that CSR communication is more likely to trigger consumer skepticism when the ambient temperature is high.  

A laboratory experiment was therefore designed and participants were randomly assigned to one of six conditions: ambient temperature that was either warm, moderate or cool and CSR communication that was motivated by either economic or ecological reasons. In addition to these controlled variables, a number of other factors were considered in order to minimize the effects of confounding, including humidity, hunger, comfort, trust in intuition, cognitive ability, gender, age, education, income, the time of the day and the day of the week. "It was a challenging task!" admits Mai. "We went as far as providing each participant with the same standardized t-shirt to wear and even measured forehead temperature."

Interesting results… with a surprise

The data gathered enabled the interaction effect between ambient temperature and CSR communication to be proved. The research also demonstrated that in warm ambient temperatures, a higher degree of skepticism is induced by ecological motives compared to economic motives. An unexpected result, however, was the discovery of a very clear gender difference with temperature-induced skepticism emerging primarily for men. Though further research is necessary to fully understand the difference, an initial exploration of the data showed a gender-specific response to increasing ambient temperatures: while men felt less comfortable, women, on the other hand, felt more comfortable.

The implications for managers and society

The research carried out not only demonstrated that temperature can influence CSR skepticism but also the negative spillover effect that it can have on the product or company. "Brand attitude may be considered to be relatively stable, but this study has shown that even very subtle contextual factors can influence how CSR communication is interpreted and that ultimately affects the consumer's perception of the brand," explains Mai. The effects are potentially even further wide-ranging as damage to the company image could ultimately deter green purchases and thus limit the market for green products. The advice for managers is to carefully consider seasonal and local temperatures when rolling out their CSR communication and in the absence of temperature knowledge or control, to limit CSR advertising to retail stores where temperature regulation is possible.

The broader challenge

Alternative advice is to encourage companies to provide compelling evidence that demonstrates the truthfulness of their CSR claims. Mai admits, however, that "the COVID crisis has illustrated that communicating facts and evidence is not always enough to convince a segment of the population with high levels of skepticism and belief in conspiracy theories. Consequently, we are now carrying out research into fake news which is an extremely challenging area for companies to address."

On the same subject

  • La France neutre en carbone en 2050
    Published on 25 August 2023

    Carbon-neutral by 2050

    Describe a day in the life of a character of your choice in a carbon-neutral society in 2050? This was the unique exercise proposed to 2nd-year students of the Grande Ecole Program (PGE) and 3rd-year international students of the Global Management...

  • La France neutre en carbone en 2050
    Published on 25 August 2023

    Neutralité carbone en 2050

    Décrivez la journée d’un personnage de votre choix dans une société neutre en carbone en 2050 ? Tel est l’exercice atypique qui a été proposé aux étudiants et étudiantes de 2e année du Programme Grande Ecole pour mieux comprendre les enjeux et défis...

  • Published on 28 April 2023

    Thomas Gillier received the CIM Best Paper Award 2022!

    Creativity and Innovation Management - CIM Best Paper Award 2022 Thomas Gillier, professor at Grenoble Ecole de Management was awarded of the Tudor Rickards and Susan Moger CIM Best paper award 2022 for his paper: "Group creativity in the wild:...

  • Un produit est-il considéré comme plus efficace pour soi ou pour les autres ?
    Published on 12 March 2022

    Un produit est-il considéré comme plus efficace pour soi ou pour les autres ?

    La plupart des recherches ayant trait au comportement des consommateurs se fondent sur un postulat : la raison principale pour laquelle les gens achètent des produits repose sur le bénéfice qu’ils en attendent en les consommant. Les limites de cette...

  • Sobriété numérique/numérique raisonné : quels rôles les entreprises ont à jouer ?
    Published on 14 January 2022

    Digital Sobriety – Using Digital Technology Sensibly: What Roles Do Companies Have to Play?

    According to Green IT, 60 to 80% of the digital industry’s environmental footprint is related to equipment if we include the impacts associated with the electricity production they consume. How Can We Overcome the Misuse of Digital Tools?

  • Sobriété numérique/numérique raisonné : quels rôles les entreprises ont à jouer ?
    Published on 13 January 2022

    Sobriété numérique : quels rôles les entreprises ont à jouer ?

    Selon Green IT, 60 à 80 % de l'empreinte environnementale du numérique porte sur les équipements, si l’on intègre les impacts associés à la production de l’électricité qu’ils consomment. Comment pallier le mésusage des outils numériques ?

  • Haon Christophe - Crédit Pierre Jayet  Copyright Agence Prisme / Pierre Jayet
    Published on 07 December 2021

    How Can You Use Rewards to Boost Product Innovation?

    A study published in the Journal of Product Innovation Management in 2020 analyzes employee-specific motivators and how they are affected by financial, recognition, and social rewards.

  • RSE : comment la température ambiante influence la perception de la communication
    Published on 07 December 2021

    RSE : comment la température ambiante influence la perception de la communication

    Les conséquences de plus en plus visibles du changement climatique, associées à des attentes plus grandes sur les questions sociétales, ont placé la responsabilité sociale des entreprises (RSE) sous les feux de la rampe. Alors que de nombreuses...

  • Haon Christophe - Crédit Pierre Jayet  Copyright Agence Prisme / Pierre Jayet
    Published on 07 December 2021

    Comment booster l’innovation produit par la récompense ?

    Une recherche, publiée en 2020 dans le Journal of Product Innovation Management par trois enseignants-chercheurs en marketing, met en lumière les ressorts de l’innovation produit par des équipes de développement. Pour cela, l’étude a analysé les...

  • Comportement des consommateurs : quelle influence a le sens des couleurs ?
    Published on 16 November 2021

    Comportement des consommateurs : quelle influence a le sens des couleurs ?

    Une étude récente a démontré comment le sens moral, associé à l’achat de produits de couleurs noir et blanc, peut influencer les comportements prosociaux des consommateurs, en générant un impact potentiel significatif sur le bien-être de la société.

  • Comportement des consommateurs : quelle influence a le sens des couleurs ?
    Published on 16 November 2021

    Color me moral: how the meaning of colors influence consumer behavior

    A recent study published in the scientific journal Psychology...

  • la pertinence d’une réponse humoristique face à l’expression du mécontentement des clients sur les médias sociaux -c -Tero Vesalainen
    Published on 16 November 2021

    Online Humor: a Positive or Negative Tool for Brands?

    Recent research provides information on the appropriateness of a humorous response to customers' expressions of dissatisfaction on social media, and on the type of humor to be used according to the brand identity

  • la pertinence d’une réponse humoristique face à l’expression du mécontentement des clients sur les médias sociaux -c -Tero Vesalainen
    Published on 16 November 2021

    Réseaux sociaux et insatisfaction client : misez sur l’humour

    Une recherche récente renseigne sur la pertinence d’une réponse humoristique face à l’expression du mécontentement des clients sur les médias sociaux, et sur la forme d’humour à employer selon l’identité de la marque.

  • swaroop govinda rao GEM Copyright Bruno Fournier
    Published on 16 October 2021

    Low-Carbon Investments: how do they impact socio-economic inequalities in Brazil?

    A study published in 2020 in the scientific journal Climate Policy measured the impact of low-carbon foreign investment on inequality, employment, and poverty in Brazil. It gives recommendations for COP26.

  • swaroop govinda rao GEM Copyright Bruno Fournier
    Published on 12 October 2021

    Les investissements bas-carbone : quels impacts sur les inégalités socio-économiques au Brésil ?

    Une étude, publiée en 2020 dans la revue scientifique Climate Policy, a mesuré l’impact des investissements étrangers bas-carbone sur les inégalités, l’emploi et la pauvreté au Brésil. Et formule des préconisations dans le cadre de la COP26.

  • la majorité des personnes qui opte pour un plat froid sous-estime sa valeur réelle en calories
    Published on 09 July 2021

    When eating cold food means eating more food

    International research shows that the temperature of a dish, depending on whether it is served hot or cold, can potentially change our perception of its objective calorie content.

  •  Les effets de la canicule à Grenoble : radiographie (c) tureau
    Published on 18 June 2021

    The Territories in Transition Chairs analyze the effects of the heat wave in Grenoble

    Grenoble Ecole de Management's Territories in Transition Chairs analyzed and quantified the stresses associated with the heat waves that hit the Grenoble basin in previous summers, in order to establish priorities for the public authorities.

  •  La Journée de la Paix économique s’empare du développement durable et responsable
    Published on 11 May 2021

    Economic Peace Day: Reinventing ourselves to preserve nature

    On June 3, 2021, the Economic Peace Research Chair at Grenoble Ecole de Management, now a Société à mission , is organizing the completely virtual Economic Peace Day. Its aim: to reconcile organizations and citizens with Nature.

  • Loïck Roche, sélectionné pour participer à la Convention des Entreprises pour le Climat (CEC)
    Published on 26 April 2021

    The fight against climate change : Loick Roche, Dean and Director of GEM, is chosen to participate in the 2021 business convention for climate change in France

    Loïck Roche, Dean and Director of Grenoble Ecole de Management (GEM), has been selected to participate in the 2021 business convention for climate change (CEC) in France, in the fight against climate change. He will be the only Business School...

  • Réseaux sociaux : doit-on encadrer les filtres de beauté ?
    Published on 13 April 2021

    Should beauty filters on social media be regulated?

    The "ETIC" research program is investigating the adverse effects that digital images can potentially cause, with specific focus on the impact that beauty filters can have on users who are most exposed to the pressures of today's beauty ideals.

  • Messages publicitaires : s’adapter aux valeurs culturelles. L’exemple de la Corée du sud
    Published on 15 March 2021

    Advertising messages: adapting to cultural values. The example of South Korea.

    A study conducted in South Korea examined the effectiveness of advertising messages broadcast in this rapidly growing market with Confucian cultural traditions, in comparison to globalized advertisements based on more individualistic values.

  • Nom de marques. Comment communiquer l’action par la sonorité ? copy metamorworks
    Published on 13 January 2021

    Brand names: How and why does sonority impact perception?

    How can the sound of a brand name influence a customer’s perception? New research explains that occlusive consonants (b, d, p, t) suggest greater action and therefore positively impact customer perceptions.

  • Accroître la valeur d'un produit de masse via la co-conception  c oksana nazarchuk
    Published on 10 January 2021

    The advantages of co-creating with customers

    Co-creation programs such as the massive online personalization program “Design your own Converse” offer interesting marketing advantages. Recent study results help us better understand the impact on customer experience and loyalty.

  • Accroître la valeur d'un produit de masse via la co-conception  c oksana nazarchuk
    Published on 10 January 2021

    Les atouts insoupçonnés de la co-conception avec des consommateurs

    Une étude, réalisée sur le programme de personnalisation de masse en ligne « Concevez votre propre chaussure » déployé par la marque Converse, nous éclaire sur les atouts marketing de la co-conception.

  • Nom de marques. Comment communiquer l’action par la sonorité ? copy metamorworks
    Published on 13 January 2021

    Nom de marques : comment communiquer l’action par la sonorité ?

    Une étude en psycholinguistique démontre comment les consonnes occlusives, telles que b, d, p et t évoquent l’action, et viennent accroître l’attractivité perçue de noms de marques par le consommateur.

  • Published on 16 November 2020

    Pour durer, les entreprises doivent-elles développer des stratégies d’innovation durable ?

    Loi sur la transition énergétique, Accord de Paris sur le climat, crise sanitaire… face aux nouvelles contraintes gouvernementales et sociétales, les entreprises doivent de plus en plus intégrer la transition énergétique dans leurs stratégies pour à...

  • Transports : êtes-vous prêts à compenser votre empreinte carbone spooh
    Published on 15 October 2020

    Do you compensate for your carbon footprint?

    As initiatives to offset carbon footprints continue to grow, a new study sheds light on travelers' willingness to pay a surcharge to compensate for their carbon footprint. Whether for professional or personal trips, there is growing potential for...

  • Transports : êtes-vous prêts à compenser votre empreinte carbone spooh
    Published on 15 October 2020

    Transports : êtes-vous prêts à compenser votre empreinte carbone ?

    La propension à payer, ou WTP (willingness to pay), est le concept selon lequel les voyageurs sont disposés à payer des frais supplémentaires, afin de compenser l’empreinte carbone générée par leur voyage

  • Service Freemium : lorsque la qualité fait la différence
    Published on 20 January 2020

    Freemium offers: quality the key to converting free users?

    Free digital services have become so commonplace that converting users to premium offers has become a major challenge for many digital companies. New research highlights quality as a key factor in successfully implementing a freemium strategy.

  • Service Freemium : lorsque la qualité fait la différence
    Published on 20 January 2020

    Service Freemium : lorsque la qualité fait la différence

    Des recherches récentes soulignent l’importance de la perception des consommateurs dans le succès d’une stratégie de service « Freemium » (gratuit + premium).

  • Le dilemme des achats responsables à Noël
    Published on 16 December 2019

    Trending: buying an ethical Christmas gift...

    Christmas is a time for giving…” or maybe a time for shopping should we say. How can Christmas shopping and sustainable consumerism join paths?

  • La Chaire Energy for Society « embarque » les citoyens dans la transition énergétique
    Published on 18 November 2019

    The Energy for Society Chair: mobilizing citizens for the energy transition

    With the growing urgency of climate change and its associated challenges, the energy transition has become of essential importance for society. As a result, the Energy for Society Chair at Grenoble Ecole de Management was launched with three...

  • Energie. La régulation des prix décourage la concurrence
    Published on 20 October 2019

    Energy: price regulation discourages competition

    A new European study analyzes the impact of price regulation on competitiveness in the European energy market. After 20 years of moving towards a liberalized energy market, the study notes that many countries report limited motivation by customers...

  • Des catalogues digitaux enrichis… Pour quoi faire ?
    Published on 16 September 2019

    Digitally enhanced catalogs… A winning promise?

    3D images, videos, detailed product files… Digitally enhanced catalogs offer a new, trendy marketing tool. Yet research confirms that such enhancements aren’t necessarily a worthy investment.

  • Des catalogues digitaux enrichis… Pour quoi faire ?
    Published on 16 September 2019

    Des catalogues digitaux enrichis… Pour quoi faire ?

    Les catalogues digitaux enrichis font une promesse : celle d’apporter une expérience unique aux consommateurs. Mais, en réalité, qu’en est-il ? Le sujet a fait l’objet de plusieurs recherches empiriques, conduites en France et en Belgique à partir...

  • L’Art peut-il avoir une influence positive sur la perception d’une marque, d’un produit ou d’un service
    Published on 21 July 2019

    Research and art: nourishing a virtuous cycle at GEM

    Can art positively influence our perception of a brand? WIth the cooperation of a local artist, GEM researchers explore the impact of art on GEM customers.

  • La recherche prospective : épicentre de l’innovation
    Published on 22 July 2019

    Forward-looking search: encouraging cutting-edge innovation

    Innovation is at the heart of business growth, in particular for dynamic sectors such as the high tech industry. To encourage radical innovation, it’s essential to integrate a future-oriented search and analysis process throughout an innovation...

  • Comment réhabiliter les sens dans un environnement numérique ?
    Published on 24 May 2019

    How to re-integrate our senses in a digital environment?

    The 90s brought sensorial experiences to physical shops. With the digital revolution, how can we bring the same experiences to digital environments?

  • Caroline Cuny, GEM
    Published on 24 January 2019

    How can you encourage the success of a new product?

    Despite great design, some new products still bomb. New research highlights that such failures could be due to a lack of harmony between product design and market position.

  • Comment l’expérience patient peut-elle revitaliser notre système de soin ?
    Published on 27 September 2018

    How can the patient experience revitalize our healthcare system?

    Renewed interest in patient feedback and improving the patient experience could mark the beginning of a patient-oriented culture. Thanks to a recent workshop, more than 60 players in the healthcare industry were able to discuss and exchange about...

  • les fondamentaux pour bien gérer son marketing personnel.
    Published on 12 July 2018

    The fundamentals of personal marketing

    Successful personal marketing is an art. How can you go beyond compulsive tweeting or an excessive use of social networks in order to create a solid strategy to build and maintain your e-reputation?

  • David Gotteland est professeur de marketing à Grenoble Ecole de Management
    Published on 21 June 2018

    How Can You Create a Reliable Innovation Process?

    Formatted, creative methods with a framework enable scientifically proven increases in innovation processes. The stakes are high as only 15% of innovative ideas at a company end up as financial and commercial successes.

  • Comment les primes influent la vente de produits neufs ou recyclés ?
    Published on 19 June 2018

    Sales Incentives: Balancing New and Remanufactured Goods

    Remanufactured goods can provide companies with higher profit margins. But, it’s essential for companies to implement a strategy that adequately balances the sale of new and remanufactured products.

  • Chirag Patel et Christophe Haon
    Published on 18 May 2018

    Research: Retail Website Performance, to Outsource or not to Outsource?

    To improve sales, retail websites focus on personalizing their web pages and increasing their influence on social networks. To achieve these goals, should they rely on internal resources or call on external service providers? A study of 105 U.S....

  • Can TV Characters Teach Us About Management?
    Published on 14 September 2017

    Can TV Characters Teach Us About Management?

    From Mad Men to The Sopranos or The Walking Dead, discover the management wisdom of characters in popular TV series.

  • fornerino-marianela
    Published on 19 April 2017

    Sensory Marketing: Reinventing the Customer Experience

    How can images, sounds, smells, touch and taste impact a customer’s intention to purchase?

  • research on Contextual Television Advertising
    Published on 28 February 2017

    Research: Questioning the Effectiveness of Contextual Television Advertising

    As businesses and marketing go digital, companies have to track the effectiveness of their advertising across many channels. The growth of online transactions has made website conversions an essential factor for many businesses. Thanks to detailed...

  • research on Contextual Television Advertising
    Published on 28 February 2017

    Recherche : Quelle efficacité pour la publicité contextuelle à la télévision ?

    Du fait de la digitalisation de leurs activités économiques et marketing, les entreprises se préoccupent de plus en plus de l’efficacité de leurs campagnes publicitaires. Le taux de conversion, mesuré comme le nombre de transactions en ligne par...

  • research on logo makeover perception
    Published on 18 October 2016

    Time for a Logo Makeover? Make it a Hit!

    A logo represents a brand’s image. It highlights its values and market position. Changing your logo can be a delicate transition. How can you ensure a smooth change? In January 2014, Grenoble Ecole de Management unveiled its new logo. Caroline Cuny...

  • research on logo makeover perception
    Published on 18 October 2016

    A nouveau logo, nouvelle image : comment réussir la transition ?

    En janvier 2014, Grenoble Ecole de Management affichait un nouveau logo, aux couleurs de ses performances et de ses orientations. Caroline Cuny et Marianela Fornerino, professeurs au département marketing à GEM, et Julien Grobert, ancien assistant...

  • Published on 19 March 2017

    Easy-to-Read Food Labels Increase Intention to Purchase

    The battle for healthy food has become a worldwide concern. Public health agencies have invested energy and resources in fighting health risks such as obesity. In this battle, food labels that indicate nutritional facts have come to play a vital...

  • Published on 19 March 2017

    Recherche : Informations nutritionnelles, gare à l’effet boomerang des efforts de clarté

    Plus la fiche d'informations nutritionnelles d'un produit est lisible et facile à assimiler, plus les intentions d'achat des consommateurs augmentent. Y compris si le produit est mauvais pour la santé ! Un éclairage inédit sur les efforts de...

  • Published on 14 September 2016

    Praticité : pour ou contre ?

    Les dispositifs techniques censés réduire les efforts inutiles, aboutiraient à une taylorisation des gestes de la vie quotidienne. Dans une tribune de The Conversation Raffi Duymedjian se questionne sur les effets néfastes de la praticité.

  • Research: Creating Visitor Engagement Through Music
    Published on 29 February 2016

    Research: Creating Visitor Engagement Through Music

    Digital communications have created an information overload for customers. To stand out on the world wide web, companies have to offer clients a high-impact experience. When used properly, music provides a simple yet effective means of creating a...

  • Published on 08 December 2015

    Book : Making Innovation Last

    « Unlike any book in our fields, this book is explicitly cross disciplinary even as it focuses on innovation streams over time… I could not recommend this book more highly; it has the potential to be a landmark contribution” Michael L. Tushman,...

  • Published on 22 June 2015

    Research: Microeconomic Degrowth, Community Supported Agriculture

    Economic growth is the cornerstone of mainstream macroeconomics. In the face of economic crises and unemployment, growth has long been the only acceptable solution. Yet many issues have started to challenge this dominant economic model. As a result...

  • Published on 16 January 2015

    Nostalgia makes consumers more likely to spend or donate money

    The use of nostalgia has been a top trend in marketing in the last few years, in commercials, product lines and even TV shows. The present study demonstrates that feeling nostalgic weakens the desire to hold on to money, and makes it easier to part...

  • Published on 16 January 2015

    Recherche : Pourquoi la nostalgie vous donne envie d’acheter

    La mode actuelle des produits « rétro » ou vintage ne doit rien au hasard. Une étude co-écrite par Jannine Lasaleta, chercheur à GEM, montre que ce qui suscite un sentiment de nostalgie réduit simultanément l’attrait pour l’argent. Le dépenser...